Apparently reviewing ads has become a national sport online because everyone and their mother think they are equipped to speak of ads when, they have no clue what they are saying (hint: if you want to quote Ogilvy at least read Ogilvy). Long story short, seeing an ad is not the same as analyzing it. If you lack depth, culture, history, ability to compare, don't have a previous repertoire, don't know the difference between client and creative brief, never wrote a brand manual with do's and dont's, and most importantly, if you think the common Lebanese person shops at supermarkets and cares about anything apart from the price point in today's economy you are reading this all wrong.
Which brings us to, people reviewing ads have no clue what the Lebanese people shop. Even brands which normally held their own for a long time are suffering. Case in point - the marketing manager of a major brand used to tell me "either we are up 5% annually or down 5%", interestingly the brand in question is now struggling in what became a much more crowded, much more price sensitive market.
I keep reading posts arguing about things that are so trivial to the Lebanese shopper. I am trying to be sensitive to these "reviewers", but let me be honest, no - not everyone drinks 4 coffee cups at 3 major chains a day, no one is going to choose between a crab salad and a fancy Labneh in pain aux olives as a mid-day meal, and no one cares about the color of the pea can on the shelf of an expensive supermarket. You are holding people by the wrong metrics, behaviors, and realities.
In other words, get down from your high horses and observe real people in real life situations.
And as the French film put it superbly, "c'est pas parce qu'on n'a rien a dire qu'il faut fermer sa gueule" (it's not because we have nothing to say that we ought to shut our trap).
